by Edd Doerr
I have just sent the following message to Eden Foods, 761 Tecumseh Road, Clinton, MI 49236 (info@edenfoods.com) ----
"Eden Foods: Our family is vegetarian. We have been using your products for years. Now we learn that your company has filed suit in federal court challenging the new healthcare law's contraceptive insurance mandate. We are appalled by this blatant kowtowing to religious fundamentalism. So we will not buy your products until we know that you have withdrawn this malicious lawsuit. Further, as a well-published writer I will be conveying this message far and wide on the internet. --- Edd Doerr (arlinc@verizon.net)
Anyone care to follow our example?
Thursday, May 09, 2013
Why everyone should be an atheist
By Mathew Goldstein
We start from scratch, from the perspective that we will give both possibilities, atheistic naturalism and theistic supernaturalism, equal opportunity to be adopted. We can define supernaturalism as immaterial willful agency and/or immaterial mind, or god. We know nothing and we are born into a universe. What would we experience in a universe where we would be properly justified to be theists, and how does that universe compare to our universe?
We need an unbiased criteria to decide. The bottom line is practical success versus failure, so that is the criteria. Success is whatever works to meet our needs and desires. We need things like food, health, shelter, we desire things like travel and knowledge. So what delivers our needs and desires?
The answer could be divine revelation. By studying the holy texts, adopting the specified beliefs, worshipping, praying, following the rituals, obeying the laws, as revealed to us by deity, we receive food, health, shelter, transportation, and knowledge. In other words, by practicing methodological supernaturalism we are successful. Given a choice of what to believe, we follow the available evidences and become theists because the universe evidences supernaturalism. However, in our universe, agriculture, medicine, housing, and transportation are human built and maintained products of human acquired knowledge, our knowledge is built exclusively on methodological naturalism, and the content of our knowledge is also naturalistic. Therefore, when we follow the available evidences we become atheists because our universe evidences naturalism.
Some theists will probably object to this argument for atheism by saying it is bad theology. Should we respect this objection? If we are committed to holding beliefs that accurately model how the universe works then we should disregard this objection. Success, not self-referencing ideology, must be our guide because success is the most plausibly unbiased criteria available to us, it is the way that our universe itself communicates to us regarding how our universe works. Lacking omniscience we lack certainty that our conclusion is correct. But such unavoidable uncertainty makes no difference. We are rationally obliged to adopt the conclusion favored by a pervasive and unchallenged track record of success.
Monday, May 06, 2013
Abelard's Early Humanist Reasoning
by Gary Berg-Cross
At
a recent conference a lunchtime conversation turned to examples of sound
reasoning and the scholar Peter Abelard was raised as an interesting example. Abelard is better known to most of us as a
tragic love story. Abelard and Heloise remain
one of the more a celebrated couples of all time, in part from their writing
and in part from the classic tragic
events that eventually separated them:
1.
two well-educated people, brought together
by their passion they fell in love;
2.
Heloise became pregnant, so
3.
they married secretly in 1118.
4.
Her uncle Fulbert,
a canon of Paris, had Abelard castrated by thugs believing that he had
abandoned Heloise,
5.
after which he became a monk and
6. Sent to a convent by her
uncle, Heloise later became a nun
In a letter to Abelard,
Heloise reflected on her loss:
"You know, beloved, as the whole world
knows, how much I have lost in you, how at one wretched stroke of fortune that
supreme act of flagrant treachery robbed me of my very self in robbing me of
you; and how my sorrow for my loss is nothing compared with what I feel for the
manner in which I lost you."
This part of the history I knew a bit, but Peter
Abelard (1079-1142) as an12th century medieval French philosopher,
theologian, and logician I had heard less about. After all these are the Middle Ages, so I was
pleasantly surprised to learn the history and form of his thinking.
It goes something like this. A bright boy
he rapidly jumped from school to school gaining an easy rise
to fame. He wound up in a pre-University of Paris
setting to study under William of Champeaux, head of the cathedral school and archdeacon
of Notre Dame. Along the way his brilliant reasoning and debate were matched
by a Chris-Hitchens-like arrogance. As with Hitch he generated many foes as wells as
admirers. His mentor William, for example, was famous
for a realist stance on the nature of universals, while pupil Peter took a nominalist and soundly won a series
of debates. This success lead to a following, among students who
provided a core for what was late to become the great University in Paris. Abélard's deep
understanding of Aristotle's theory of knowledge surpassed anything widely
available in 12th century Europe, which he cultivated in his Paris
students. His was an example of great teaching that came to live as a Liberal Arts curriculum and style of teaching when universities were formally founded.
One of his important contributions was a work on
ethics which took as its title the Socratic admonition, "Know
thyself." In this work Abelard veered
from the established course of strict commandments to stress the importance of
intention in evaluating the moral/immoral character of an action. This was a step towards more nuanced reasoning about moral action.
Some of his early persuasive arguments swayed leaders like Pope Innocent III, who accepted Abelard's Doctrine of
Limbo – children are innocent before the age of reason. But reasoned debate about reason itself was his
real forte and passion - outside of Heloise. A famous debate was with Bernard of
Clairvaux over the conflicts of reason and religion. This conflict that made him a hero of the Enlightenment.
In Dialogue of a Philosopher with a Jew and a Christian Abelard plays a combination of a Socrates and Swift like character as he debated religious dogma. Abélard juxtaposes apparently contradictory quotations from the Church Fathers & the Bible on many of the traditional topics of Judeo-Christian theology (he was the first to use ‘theology’ in its modern sense) only to “discover(ed) the Jews to be stupid and the Christians insane.” As you can imagine making common folks reasoning look foolish does get noticed. His teachings backed by sound reasoning were controversial, and he was repeatedly charged with heresy. His book on the Trinity was condemned to be burnt at Soissons in 1121.
In Dialogue of a Philosopher with a Jew and a Christian Abelard plays a combination of a Socrates and Swift like character as he debated religious dogma. Abélard juxtaposes apparently contradictory quotations from the Church Fathers & the Bible on many of the traditional topics of Judeo-Christian theology (he was the first to use ‘theology’ in its modern sense) only to “discover(ed) the Jews to be stupid and the Christians insane.” As you can imagine making common folks reasoning look foolish does get noticed. His teachings backed by sound reasoning were controversial, and he was repeatedly charged with heresy. His book on the Trinity was condemned to be burnt at Soissons in 1121.
One
can see the controversy in one his works on Logic Reasoning "Sic et
Non," an early scholastic teaching text whose title translates from
Medieval Latin into a simple “Yes and No" dichotomy (for more on limitations of dichotomy see my article on Binary Thinking). As in his previous “Dialog”
we see what happens
when we apply
reason to the teaching of revelation or at least questions that come out of
revealed truths.
In the Prologue, Abélard outlines logical rules for
reconciling contradictions but the core of the book is a list of 158
philosophical and theological questions. The first five questions give a sense of these:
- Must human
faith be completed by reason, or not?
- Does faith
deal only with unseen things, or not?
- Is there
any knowledge of things unseen, or not?
- May one
believe only in God alone, or not?
- Is God a
single unitary being, or not?
Abelard laid down four
basic principles of reasoning:
- Use systematic doubt
and question everything
- Learn the difference between statements of rational proof and those merely of
persuasion
- Be precise
in use of words, and expect precision of others
- Watch for error,
even in Holy Scripture (danger Will Robinson!!)
One can why Peter got in trouble as the rational arguments on the non-doctrinaire
side seem as good as the Church’s position. And rational argument is still getting freethinkers in trouble.
Abelard was probably not the forerunner of modern atheism as some have argued. He seems more comfortably fit into a proud
humanistic tradition–extending from Socrates. He takes a bold Medieval step towards human
centering in ethics by taking moral authority and responsibility away from gods
and their servant. Intentions and reasoning make it our responsibility. Bravo Peter A for your love of reason and
balance along with the worthy Heloise.
Images
A & H : http://www.patheos.com/blogs/danpeterson/2012/04/sic-et-non-why-the-title.html
and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_philosophy
A Dialogue of a Philosopher With a Jew, and a Christian: http://books.google.com/books/about/A_Dialogue_of_a_Philosopher_With_a_Jew_a.html?id=j6lLgt-bhBAC
Wednesday, May 01, 2013
Ontologists Discuss the God Meme & Its Arguments
By Gary Berg-Cross
The ontolog-forum can be a fun thing to read about semantic topics and our understanding of reality.
It can also generate off-topic discussion thread and a recent one concerned Dennett’s God meme ("an idea, behavior, or style that spreads from person to person within a culture.) as the primary application of memes that seems to interest both Dawkins and Dennett.
Memes were already being discussed when someone through in a reference to Giussani's "The Religious Sense"
some reflection of an driving need for truth, goodness, and beauty. Giussani is the founder the lay Catholic ecclesial movement Communion and Liberation (CL), similar to the Neo-Catechumenal Way, Foculare, and Opus Dei. He writes popular books to spread memes, I guess, and in "The Religious Sense" his pushes the idea that values of truth and beauty constitutes the fabric of the religious sense, which is evident in every human being everywhere and in all times.
Ontologists on the forum are not shy about taking shabby arguments to task. I thought that
readers of this Blog be interested in here some of the argument and exchange.
Polymath John Sowa responded briskly, and tongue in cheek, as it were:
I'm willing to grant that all arguments for the existence of God are unscientific.
But I also believe that all arguments *against* the existence
of God are equally unscientific. It's actually harderto develop
a solid proof that something does *not* exist.
That's why I recommended that any exploration of the "god meme"
should be based on a study of gods such as Zeus, which don't
seem to be tied up with much emotion, either pro or con.
An equally deep
and insightful Pat Hayes added to
the put down with an appeal to the flying spaghetti monster.
The basic scientific argument against the existence of God is that there is
absolutely no observational evidence for the existence of a God, nor any reason to hypothesize such an entity in order to explain anything that is observable. A very straightforward application of Occam's principle then suffices. Of course this is not a *proof*, but it is a sound *scientific* argument. Proofs are irrelevant here. There is no proof that the flying spaghetti monster does not exist, but that does not shake the faith of the true Pastafarian.
Matthew West picked up in the
proof idea to add:
All one can say
scientifically is that the existence of God is a hypothesis that it is unlikely
that we will ever be able to prove or disprove scientifically, because there is
no experiment that we can conduct (or at least I cannot think of any) that
would prove or disprove the hypothesis. (Of course you can always set up God
hypotheses that you can disprove, but they are not generally ones the
"faithful" actually believe in).
As to Pat’s There is no proof that the flying spaghetti monster does not exist, but that does not shake the faith of the true Pastafarian.
Matthew added:
And that is the essence. It is a matter of faith, not science. So any
scientific argument is irrelevant. Irritating though that may be to those
who believe only in science.
Pat disagreed a bit here saying
No, this makes the situation seem symmetrical. But science is not symmetrical in this way: one only has a burden to show something that is hypothesized in
order to explain something else. God does not explain anything that cannot be
explained better without using that hypothesis. Every attempt throughout
history to offer an argument for the existence of God (e.g. to explain the
cosmos, to explain life, to explain morality) has turned out to be wrong. Every
one, without exception. I would say that this was pretty convincing argument, myself.
As for experiments, how about the recent empirical tests of the efficacy of prayer? (In sum: it has zero effect.)
Oh brave freethinking people out there.
Images
John Sowa: http://www.jfsowa.com/pubs/
Pat Hayes: http://www.ihmc.us/groups/phayes/
Tuesday, April 30, 2013
Recommended Reads
by Edd Doerr
Looking for some good reads? Then let me recommend the novels of Arturo Perez-Reverte, the Spanish novelist, journalist, columnist and former war correspondent (born 1951 in Cartagena, Spain). His two dozen novels are nearly all readily available in English. I have read over half of them in Spanish, but they translate well into English.
His seven Captain Alatriste novels are about a Spanish soldier during the period of Dumas' Three Musqueteers. Especially good is Purity of Blood, about the Inquisition and Spanish anti-Semitism.
He has written several about the Napoleonic wars, including a rather comic one, The Shadow of the Eagle, about Napoleon's 1812 invasion of Russia. His Cape Trafalgar deals with the battle that made Nelson famous. The Fencing Master and The Nautical Chart are mysteries, the first in 1868 Madrid and the second, as good as anything by Melville, Stevenson, or Conrad, is a contemporary story that makes The Maltese Falcon look simple.
On the whole, I'd say that Perez-Reverte compares favorably with Hemingway.
His books of collected columns are terrific but available, unfortunately, only in Spanish.
I met the author in Washington several years ago and was impressed.
Looking for some good reads? Then let me recommend the novels of Arturo Perez-Reverte, the Spanish novelist, journalist, columnist and former war correspondent (born 1951 in Cartagena, Spain). His two dozen novels are nearly all readily available in English. I have read over half of them in Spanish, but they translate well into English.
His seven Captain Alatriste novels are about a Spanish soldier during the period of Dumas' Three Musqueteers. Especially good is Purity of Blood, about the Inquisition and Spanish anti-Semitism.
He has written several about the Napoleonic wars, including a rather comic one, The Shadow of the Eagle, about Napoleon's 1812 invasion of Russia. His Cape Trafalgar deals with the battle that made Nelson famous. The Fencing Master and The Nautical Chart are mysteries, the first in 1868 Madrid and the second, as good as anything by Melville, Stevenson, or Conrad, is a contemporary story that makes The Maltese Falcon look simple.
On the whole, I'd say that Perez-Reverte compares favorably with Hemingway.
His books of collected columns are terrific but available, unfortunately, only in Spanish.
I met the author in Washington several years ago and was impressed.
Separation Strategies
by Edd Doerr
Of late there has been some blogging about strategies and priorities in defending separation of church and state. Following is a back story on this that has never before appeared in print.
In 1971 the Supreme Court ruled, in Lemon v Kurtzman, against Pennsylvania and Rhode Island laws diverting public funds to religious private schools. This was the Court's first ruling on this important matter and was followed by three decades of similar rulings. Why was this the first such case? For the simple reason that from 1924 until 1968 taxpayers did not have "standing" in federal courts to challenge government spending believed to violate the First Amendment church-state separation principle. But in 1968, in Flast v Cohen, a case argued in part by Sen Sam Ervin (D-TN), the Court granted standing. Unfortunately, the Court at the same time also upheld a NY law that allowed the state to pay for textbooks for use in parochial schools.
Let's back up to 1969 or 1970 (I do not keep a diary, so dates are approximate). I was the Sunday morning speaker on church-state separation and religious freedom at a Unitarian church in Cleveland. After the service a guy identified himself as a member of the Ohio state board education and told me that a lawsuit by Americans United in state court challenging some state aid to church schools was so badly handled that it was such a sure loser and the separationists on the state board were worried. When I returned to Washington, where I had been on the Americans United staff since 1966 (I edited their Church & State magazine from 1970 to 1982), I reported the matter to AU executive director Glenn Archer, who was not worried. However, Gaston Cogdell on the AU staff (he was the guy who had recruited me for the AU staff) was plenty worried. At his own expense he flew to Ohio (where he had served as a minister) and tried to persuade the plaintiff in the case to drop it. Archer fired Cogdell forfhis and said he would fire me if I did not quit defending Cogdell. Later the suit was just allowed to die.
Meanwhile, Pennsylvania had passed a law to divert a tiny percentage of the cigarette tax to the support of parochial schools and Rhode Island had passed similar legislation. AU's Archer sent staff attorney Franklin Salisbury to Harrisburg to find a local attorney to challenge the state law. The very day that Salisbury (a lousy attorney in my opinion) was in Harrisburg the ACLU and other groups were meeting in Philadelphia to plan a major coalition lawsuit. So Archer sent me to Philly for that meeting. On my return to Washington I urged Archer not to file a separate suit but to join the coalition suit in Philly. The attorney retained pro bono (as I recall) by the coalition was the distinguished Henry Sawyer, the attorney who had won the Schempp case on school prayer in the Supreme Court in 1962. Archer agreed with me and the rest is history.
Lemon (and the famous "Lemon test" held for three decades, until the by then conservative Supreme Court issued the disastrous ruling in 2002 upholding the Ohio school voucher plan.
The moral of all this is that, with a conservative Supreme Court, legal actions defending separation need to be carefully planned. Priorities need to be decided on. Reckless kamikaze lawsuits, like Newdow's sure loser challenge to "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance could have serious irreversible negative consequences for the whole country.
I invite comments.
(Doerr is president of Americans for Religious Liberty [arlinc.org] and has been a full-time church-state separation activist for nearly 50 years.)
Of late there has been some blogging about strategies and priorities in defending separation of church and state. Following is a back story on this that has never before appeared in print.
In 1971 the Supreme Court ruled, in Lemon v Kurtzman, against Pennsylvania and Rhode Island laws diverting public funds to religious private schools. This was the Court's first ruling on this important matter and was followed by three decades of similar rulings. Why was this the first such case? For the simple reason that from 1924 until 1968 taxpayers did not have "standing" in federal courts to challenge government spending believed to violate the First Amendment church-state separation principle. But in 1968, in Flast v Cohen, a case argued in part by Sen Sam Ervin (D-TN), the Court granted standing. Unfortunately, the Court at the same time also upheld a NY law that allowed the state to pay for textbooks for use in parochial schools.
Let's back up to 1969 or 1970 (I do not keep a diary, so dates are approximate). I was the Sunday morning speaker on church-state separation and religious freedom at a Unitarian church in Cleveland. After the service a guy identified himself as a member of the Ohio state board education and told me that a lawsuit by Americans United in state court challenging some state aid to church schools was so badly handled that it was such a sure loser and the separationists on the state board were worried. When I returned to Washington, where I had been on the Americans United staff since 1966 (I edited their Church & State magazine from 1970 to 1982), I reported the matter to AU executive director Glenn Archer, who was not worried. However, Gaston Cogdell on the AU staff (he was the guy who had recruited me for the AU staff) was plenty worried. At his own expense he flew to Ohio (where he had served as a minister) and tried to persuade the plaintiff in the case to drop it. Archer fired Cogdell forfhis and said he would fire me if I did not quit defending Cogdell. Later the suit was just allowed to die.
Meanwhile, Pennsylvania had passed a law to divert a tiny percentage of the cigarette tax to the support of parochial schools and Rhode Island had passed similar legislation. AU's Archer sent staff attorney Franklin Salisbury to Harrisburg to find a local attorney to challenge the state law. The very day that Salisbury (a lousy attorney in my opinion) was in Harrisburg the ACLU and other groups were meeting in Philadelphia to plan a major coalition lawsuit. So Archer sent me to Philly for that meeting. On my return to Washington I urged Archer not to file a separate suit but to join the coalition suit in Philly. The attorney retained pro bono (as I recall) by the coalition was the distinguished Henry Sawyer, the attorney who had won the Schempp case on school prayer in the Supreme Court in 1962. Archer agreed with me and the rest is history.
Lemon (and the famous "Lemon test" held for three decades, until the by then conservative Supreme Court issued the disastrous ruling in 2002 upholding the Ohio school voucher plan.
The moral of all this is that, with a conservative Supreme Court, legal actions defending separation need to be carefully planned. Priorities need to be decided on. Reckless kamikaze lawsuits, like Newdow's sure loser challenge to "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance could have serious irreversible negative consequences for the whole country.
I invite comments.
(Doerr is president of Americans for Religious Liberty [arlinc.org] and has been a full-time church-state separation activist for nearly 50 years.)
Saturday, April 27, 2013
A Cultural May Evening in DC
by Gary Berg-Cross
DC offers some interesting cultural (and free)opportunities. One of them I heard about recently is SEAD - The network for Sciences, Engineering, Arts and Design. SEAD broad goal is to facilitate research, dialogue, and communication within and among those working in the SEAD disciplines. .It's one of those active communities that working towards:
"healthy development of neighborhoods, cities and regions and our competitive edge in economic, educational, and social wellbeing relies upon new ways of thinking as well as transformative efforts that integrate disciplines and domains. "
There ideas on "transdisciplinary, collaborative work that combines aspects of arts, humanities, sciences, and engineering for fostering innovation to improve health, education, productivity and community sustainability" sounds interesting and I'll be glad to learn more about all of this at the Thursday May 16, 2013 meeting at the D.C. Art Science Evening Rendezvous (DASER) (doors open at 5:30)
It's at the Keck Center, 500 Fifth St., N.W., Room 100.
DASER co-sponsored by Cultural Programs of the National Academy of Sciences (CPNAS) and Leonardo, the International Society for the Arts, Sciences, and Technology is itself an interesting cultural institution.
DASER fosters community and discussion around the intersection of art and science. providing:
" a snapshot of the cultural environment and foster interdisciplinary networking. "
Here is some additional info on what promises to be a great DASER session with really interesting speakers:
5:30 to 6:00 p.m. Check in
6:00 to 6:10 p.m. Welcoming remarks and community sharing.
Anyone in the audience currently working within the intersections of art and science will have 30 seconds (or so) to share their work. These are usually presented as teasers so that those who are interested can seek you out during social & networking time following the event.
6:10 to 7:10 p.m. Panelists' presentations (15 minutes or so each) For May the schedule is like this:
Roger Malina, Distinguished Professor of Art and Technology,6:00 to 6:10 p.m. Welcoming remarks and community sharing.
Anyone in the audience currently working within the intersections of art and science will have 30 seconds (or so) to share their work. These are usually presented as teasers so that those who are interested can seek you out during social & networking time following the event.
6:10 to 7:10 p.m. Panelists' presentations (15 minutes or so each) For May the schedule is like this:
and Professor of Physics, University of Texas, Dallas and
Executive Editor, Leonardo Publications, MIT Press
Gunalan Nadarajan Dean, School of Art and Design, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
Bill O'Brien Senior Advisor for Program Innovation
National Endowment for the Arts, Washington, D.C.
Carol Strohecker, Director, Center for Design Innovation,
University of North Carolina system, Winston-Salem
After Discussion around 8 or so there is a 8:10 to 9:00 p.m. Reception
You can register for this DASER event at http://may16daser.eventbrite.com/#
Visit CPNAS's website for more information: http://www.cpnas.org/events/051613.html
Monday, April 22, 2013
Happy Earth Day
by Gary Berg-Cross
Along with natures' freebie of the 17 year brood II cicadas we have Earth Day to celebrate this spring in DC. It's one of my favorite things to celebrate and I wrote this to enjoy and remember it with my grandchildren.
You and I are part of the earth, connected & united with all its life, and everything else that is on this planet and home we call EARTH.
It deservers our love, respect and care.
Today especially, but every day you, me and everyone else should wake up with the idea that we will be a good steward for the planet.
Wake up with the idea that you (and I) will do something special to make our home earth a better, stronger and safer place for all life.
Along with natures' freebie of the 17 year brood II cicadas we have Earth Day to celebrate this spring in DC. It's one of my favorite things to celebrate and I wrote this to enjoy and remember it with my grandchildren.
You and I are part of the earth, connected & united with all its life, and everything else that is on this planet and home we call EARTH.
It deservers our love, respect and care.
Today especially, but every day you, me and everyone else should wake up with the idea that we will be a good steward for the planet.
Wake up with the idea that you (and I) will do something special to make our home earth a better, stronger and safer place for all life.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)










