Sunday, June 29, 2025

The liberal misinformation bubble

 By Mathew Goldstein


I once believed that information dispensed from liberal sources and institutions is more accurate and reliable than the blatantly and frequently distorted and misleading information dispensed from conservative sources and institutions. I no longer believe that. Leftist oriented commentators are also a major source of systematically biased, one-sidedly selective, story telling, the shameless dissemination of misinformation, and as committed to using almost any opportunity to politicize almost everything as rightist oriented commentatorsThis article published in the Atlantic magazine aligns completely with my perspective:  THE LIBERAL MISINFORMATION BUBBLE ABOUT YOUTH GENDER MEDICINE.


For decades doctors have been prescribing puberty blockers to treat precocious puberty. To argue that therefore it is a double standard to not treat gender dysphoria with puberty blockers requires overlooking the substantial difference between short term use of puberty blockers to delay puberty and a longer term use to cancel puberty. From a biological perspective it should be self-evident that delaying early puberty is less likely to have long lasting negative health impacts than preventing puberty from progressing. Equal protection before the law is not a compelling argument for reaching a conclusion that puberty blockers must be prescribed to treat gender dysphoria for minors without better evidence of no harm.

Saturday, June 21, 2025

Detecting androgenization when it is relevant

 By Mathew Goldstein


Here is an animated video on how sex screening in sports would work to protect female competition. This is what should happen for all serious adult sports competition contexts where there is sufficient money to provide the needed funding. It is a simple, irrefutable, fact that people gain a set of physical advantages that have a significant degree of relevance for many sports competition contexts as a result of androgenization relative to people who have not undergone androgenization. Androgenization begins in the womb and continues through childhood but these advantages mostly manifest during puberty. Acknowledging that trans-women as a group are in some respects different from women who are not trans and that trans-men are collectively to some extent different from men who are not trans does not sanction invidious discrimination against trans people nor endorse any false, negative over-generalizations regarding trans people.